Close
  • Existing customers
  • Help
  • Home
  • Pet policies
  • Pet guides
  • About us
Open menu Bought By Many
Existing customers
  • Pet policies
  • Pet guides
  • About us

Lemonade: What's Not To Like?

Sam Gilbert By Sam Gilbert 27th September 2016

There's a lot to love about Lemonade, the much-hyped US insurtech which finally launched its first insurance products last week.

  • The bot-like interaction design of its home insurance quote journey is delightful. Building on Guevara (sadly it closed in 2017) and others, it moves the customer experience of buying insurance on a mobile device on from the tedious process of form-filling.
  • Its pricing is keen. The acid test for all B2C fintechs is delivering tangible value to customers that incumbents can't match. Starting at just $5 a month for renters insurance, Lemonade's prices are around 50% cheaper than its direct competitors'. That's excellent.
  • Its business model is refreshingly different. Like InShared in the Netherlands, Lemonade takes a fixed percentage of insurance premiums to fund its operations. Any underwriting surplus is donated to charity as a nudge to discourage exaggerated claims. This adds up to a compelling proposition for investors as well as customers.

So what's not to love?

  • It's only available in New York. Like other US insurtechs, Lemonade faces the absurd constraints of the US's anachronistic state-based system of insurance licensing and regulation.

    After $730m of funding, Health Insurance disruptor Oscar is still only available in 4 states. Pay-per-mile car insurer Metromile is only available in 7, and has had to spend $192m acquring a traditional carrier to enable national expansion. (Yes, that's right - "national expansion", not "international expansion".)

    This is a barrier to insurance innovation that's as big and dumb as a border wall. It's a shame for US insurance startups like Lemonade, but it's also odd that insurtech VCs don't invest more in Europe, where the regulatory environment is far more benign.

  • Lemonade's policy documents consist of 20+ pages of turgid legalese. Here's a random soundbite to give you a flavour: "This Exclusion E.2. applies but is not limited to an act or omission, regardless of its nature or circumstance, involving a service or duty rendered, promised, owed, or implied to be provided because of the nature of the "business"."

    This is the kind of old-school, obfuscating language that undermines trust between insurance companies and their customers. What's more, because it uses a standard wording written in 2010 by the Insurance Services Office, Lemonade's policy is literally identical to home insurance policies from thousands of other organizations (the Kentucky FAIR Plan, for example).

    In fairness to Lemonade, this too may be a function of US regulatory constraints. But why not have Fairer Finance review documentation for clear design and simple language? Why not look at Google data to see what unmet insurance needs people have, and build new policies that meet them? Customers deserve better policies, as well as a better experience and a better price.

"Finding this site to get insurance for our amazing puppy was so fantastic, excellent price and fabulous cover. Easy to use and quick and ..."

Fiona Anglin Fiona Anglin
Read more testimonials

Want to see insurance change for the better? Add your voice to a Bought By Many group.

Join Bought By Many

Related Offers

  • Home and Contents Insurance for Over 50s
  • Home Contents Insurance for Golfers
  • Home Insurance for Horse Riders
  • Home Insurance For Switchers
  • Home Insurance offers
  • Tweet
More like this:

Why UK FinTech Needs Its Hand Bitten

I've just been enjoying the photo gallery from the recent Fintech Innovation awards. It was a gr...

  • by Sam Gilbert

What we talk about when we talk about Fintech

I looked at the last 3 months' worth of internet search data to see what's top of the collective ...

  • by Sam Gilbert

Multi Award Winning UK Fintech Startup Bought By Many Announces China Launch

Bought By Many, the UK startup using social media to disrupt the insurance industry, today announ...

  • by Steven Mendel

Awards, Uber, and Changing Insurance for the Better

I am hugely proud that Bought By Many won the Insurance Startup Award at last night's BIAs. It i...

  • by Steven Mendel

What Google data tells us about how demand for insurance is changing

Analysing internet search data can yield fascinating insights into people’s needs and desires. S...

  • by Sam Gilbert

Is Facebook the future of insurance?

Two years ago, technology researcher Gartner predicted that by the end of 2014 one of the major s...

  • by Steven Mendel
  • Reviews & guides
  • About
  • Jobs
  • Testimonials
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • International
  • Help

Bought By Many Ltd is a company registered in England and Wales with number 7886430. Address: 1-10 Summers Street, London EC1R 5BD. Bought By Many Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority - Register number 652623. This register can be checked for details of our permissions, history and contact details.