Close
  • Existing customers
  • Help
  • Home
  • Pet policies
  • Pet guides
  • About us
Open menu Bought By Many
Existing customers
  • Pet policies
  • Pet guides
  • About us

Why Home Insurance often pays out less than you expect

Steven Mendel By Steven Mendel 3rd November 2014

There was an article in the Sunday Times recently, entitled ‘Insurers sidestep contents payouts’. In it, Ali Hussain detailed the rising number of complaints that the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) has been receiving from policyholders who have been disappointed when their insurers have not paid out in full on a household insurance claim, on the basis that the policyholder wasn’t adequately insured.

To understand the assertion from the insurers it is important to understand a little-known and even less understood insurance phrase called the Principle of Average.

To best explain this jargon, let me show you the consequences of not understanding it:

    1. You have a household contents policy which insures your possessions for, let’s say, £25,000.
    2. You took out the policy a number of years ago and since then the cost of many of your possessions has increased in value (eg gold and silver jewellery), you have also been buying – you now own a large flat screen TV, some Apple kit, a new and expensive lounge suite, as well as many smaller purchases (such as clothing). In fact the total cost of replacing everything you now own is £50,000. Yet your insurance policy is still languishing at £25,000, half the current value.

    So what, you might say, I’m never going to be burgled and loose over £25,000 of my stuff. To understand how an insurer would view this issue imagine the worst happens and you have a fire at home, or simply a burst pipe in loft – even if everything was ruined you are still only insured for £25,000. So the total payout could never be more than £25,000, ie half of what you need. Perhaps more usefully consider that you do have a burglary. You lose £5,000 of your possessions. Your insurer sees that you are underinsured by half and so only can pay you half of what you need to replace the stolen possessions.

    The Principle of Average is very hard to get – in fact some years ago I was marking an actuarial exam that contained a question asking for this concept to be explained. Most of the papers I saw just couldn’t do so. So if trainee actuaries struggle with it, it’s not surprising that the FOS is worried about the issue. But I doubt it will get resolved quickly, so in the meantime, please, please take the time to work out how much your possessions add up to (this is easiest done on a room by room basis) and make sure you are adequately covered, otherwise risk being much better acquainted with this Principle.

"Very happy that there is an insurance policy that listens to what the owners and pets need with more realistic prices. Well done Bought ..."

Lynn Bowes Lynn Bowes
Read more testimonials

Want to see insurance change for the better? Then add your voice to a Bought By Many group.

Join Bought By Many

Related Offers

  • Home Contents Insurance for Golfers
  • Home Insurance for Cyclists
  • Home Insurance for Foster Carers
  • Home Insurance for Horse Riders
  • Insurance for Family Homes
  • Tweet
More like this:

Winston Wolf and the Sad Truth about Insurance Advertising

Props to Direct Line: the latest Winston Wolfe advert actually says something useful about their ...

  • by Sam Gilbert

In (Facebook) friends we trust

Why insurers should put customers in charge of driving referrals. When Facebook turned 10, Mar...

  • by Hazel McHugh

Is Facebook the future of insurance?

Two years ago, technology researcher Gartner predicted that by the end of 2014 one of the major s...

  • by Steven Mendel

Best Home Insurance Deals, Q4 2014

Renewing your home insurance in the next 3 months? Here are our top picks of the best home insur...

  • by Sam Gilbert
  • Reviews & guides
  • About
  • Jobs
  • Testimonials
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • International
  • Help

Bought By Many Ltd is a company registered in England and Wales with number 7886430. Address: 1-10 Summers Street, London EC1R 5BD. Bought By Many Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority - Register number 652623. This register can be checked for details of our permissions, history and contact details.